[HPforGrownups] Karkaroff (was Re: Hufflepuffs have evil potential?)

[Magda Grantwich]

No: HPFGUIDX 17488

> How do we know that Karkaroff didn't go back to V?  

Because JKR would have mentioned it.  A really good fiction writer
would not have left a thread that big dangling in the last chapter. 
What would be the point?

Perhaps he will return to the DEs in the fifth or sixth book but
considering his lack of backbone, I doubt that Lord V. would use him
for anything but target practice.


> How about Snape as the coward who will be punished...

Why do you think Snape is a coward? 

> and Fudge as the one who has left forever who will be killed?

I would be surprised if Fudge was more than at best a bureaucratic
twit or at worst a ministry turncoat funneling secrets to the Dark
Side without doing anything icky that might stain his robes.  He's
not important enough to be categorized that way by Lord V.

And his antics at the end of GoF certainly don't look like a man
who's absolutely free of suspicion of working for the Dark Side.


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Auctions - buy the things you want at great prices
http://auctions.yahoo.com/