Another rant :-), was Harry Potter and the Bible

[rabanesss at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 17642

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Becca" <rboswell at m...> wrote:

>If you see something wrong with the Harry 
>Potter books, then there is something wrong with Tolkein, C.S. 
>Lewis,  Douglas Adams, Terry Pratchett, and most Science 
>Fiction or Fantasy writers.  

 ANSWER---------Untrue. I have an entire chapter devoted to 
comparing the Rowling books with those of Lewis, and Tolkien. 
Also , I love Pratchett's work. He's hysterical.



>In fact, if there is a problem with the morality of Harry Potter, 
>then there is a problem with the morality of every single book 
>that has a good against evil plot.  

ANSWER-------untrue. Rowling handles the so-called good vs. 
evil very diffferently in her tales. her tale is actually one of 
HORRENDOUS evil vs. mild badness (not really good).


>Want to debate with the readers of the world?  You'll lose 
>miserably.

ANSWER--------------Well, I happen to BE one of teh readers of 
the world. And I would be glad to debate anyone, anywhere, 
anytime. Set it up, I'll be there. I doubt I will lose, let alone 
miserably. Now, I suppose I wil be clled arrogant for that. Oh 
well.

R. Abanes