Dementors Kiss (was Re: Crouch and the bone!)

[meckelburg at foni.net]

No: HPFGUIDX 17721

Thanks Doreen for supporting my Idea!
Of course it could be a red hering, but why would JKR make Crouch 
jr. turn his father's body into a bone without a reason. If it was 
just to hide him, he could have used a stone, a tree or anything 
else!
I think it is a hint, because nobody mentions it again, after the 
veritaeserum scene, so it will produce exactly the kind of "AHA"- 
effect JKR loves to create!
Mecki

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., nera at r... wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Scott" <insanus_scottus at y...> wrote:
> > Mecki wrote:
> > "Voldemort returned to life, after taking the "bone fo the father" 
> > (paraphrasing).When Crouch jr. had killed his father, he turned 
him 
> > into a bone and buried him. Could that mean, that V. has a 
> > possibility to renew the soul-less Crouch with the same potion he 
> > used to renew his body? Any Ideas?
> > "I do believe we will see crouch jr. again."
> > 
> > Doreen wrote:
> > "Very interesting point, and just the kind of hint that JKR writes 
> > that we go back and look at *after* JKR explains it to us via 
> > Dumbledore at the end of the books."
> > 
> > --Hmmm...I don't think that's likely at all. It's a good point, 
but 
> > Crouch's body doesn't need restoration does it? The body itself is 
> > perfectly healthy and fine, except for the fact that it lacks a 
> soul. 
> > (The idea is really disturbing. *shudders*) 
> 
> ********************
> Well, what if a different spell, similar in nature, but not the 
exact 
> one that Voldie used, were possible? Using Meckie's idea, is it 
> possible that a particular spell is out there somewhere to bring 
back 
> a soul-sucked individual can return to his original state?
> No, Voldie was not *dead*. Crouch is not *dead* either. Therefore, 
if 
> a dark arts spell can bring back Voldie to his original state, why 
> not Crouch or anyone else who has been soul-kissed? Who knows what 
> magic is hidden in some of those old spell books. 
> 
> Doreen, who still likes Mecky's idea & vampires & Hagrid