The Elusive Harry Fortnight
aprilgc at ivillage.com
aprilgc at ivillage.com
Thu Apr 26 16:54:42 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 17735
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., Amber <reanna20 at y...> wrote:
>
> --- linman6868 at a... wrote:
> > Anyway, that's old news. I was wondering further, after some people posted about why we're not talking about Harry as enthusiastically as Ron or Hermione, why this seems to be the case. Someone (I forgot who) said it was because Harry is more boring than the rest of them.
Amber wrote:
> Hmmm, I don't quite think it's that. As you mentioned in your post, we see the wizarding world mostly through Harry's eyes and thoughts.
...and we see the magic of the list? I can't find the post, so maybe
I'm wrong (and my relative new-ness adds to the possibility).
It seems to me that I recall one of the problems with the extension of
Ron week being that someone (who did, in fact remain pregnant till
Harry week) might not be around to discuss Harry. Do we think there's
any truth to the rumors flying about that such a person (name omitted
because she has not been officially charged with an offense) cast a
"Snape Discussion Charm" (SDC) on the listmembers? Knowing, as she
does, that Snape fans (and anti-fans) are truly imaginative and
prolific in their messages, she allegedly cast the charm. The SDC ran
away with the list. Discussions concerned everything from Snape's
behavior to his personal hygiene. Or is it only coincidence that the
cries of "We really need to discuss Harry!" are building momentum only
a few days before the individual in question is slated to be back home
(with her computer).
Rumor has it that MoM officials are investigating these serious
allegations.
Neeta Skeeter (no relation)
Congratulations on the new baby!
On Harry...
I think he's going to be a somewhat different character in the next
book. I think the weaknesses we see now -- pride, stubbornness,
unwillingness to trust adults, lack of intense study of wizard (&
Potter) history -- are going to evolve based on the events in GoF.
His pride was pointed out to him (by BC, jr. of all people). His lack
of knowledge about Neville's background was pointedly questioned by
Dumbledore.
I'm thinking he's going to spend whatever part of the summer he stays
with the Dursleys reliving the major events of GoF and trying to figure
out what, if anything, he could have done differently. I think he's
going to try to make himself better/stronger so that he won't have to
helplessly witness the death of someone he cares about.
My rationale?
As far as the "reliving", that's natural. Unfortunately, for Harry,
the Dursleys aren't likely to care about the things he's been through,
and take care to occupy him (get his mind off it). If his summers go
as usual, then aside from occasional cooking/cleaning and possible
homework (which will also trigger memories), Harry won't have much to
do but think about what he "could/should" have done.
I think Year 5 will see him more involved in the lives of other
Gryffindors. (Can't let BCjr be right about him, and he feels bad
about knowing so little about Neville, and about N's situation. The
thought was something along the lines of "Neville should be the one
getting the sympathy, not me", but I don't have GoF, and can't quote or
give reference.
I think "constant vigilance" is going to be stuck in his head (so to
speak) not only in the memories of "Moody", but because if Harry had
been more vigilant, then maybe... (speaking from Harry's POV). In GoF,
Harry seemed to be becoming more willing to trust adults, but then Rita
told lies about him, he trusted "Moody", and Fudge turned against him
(and he thinks he saw a gleam in Dumbledore's eye). I think adults
come across as fickle, if not downright untrustworthy - he may pull
back some from the trust he was developing.
I also think he's going to (in his rehashing) remember hearing
Dumbledore say to round up the old crowd, remember hearing the name
"Arabella Figg", and wonder how common a name "Figg" is. Maybe he'll
even ask, "Uh, Uncle Vernon, what's Mrs. Figg's first name?" <vbg>
Thoughts, opinions, ideas all welcome.
a.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive