[HPforGrownups] Partial transcript (was Crookshanks *is* part-Kneazle)

Morag Traynor moragt at hotmail.com
Sun Apr 29 02:20:37 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 17927

<snip useful transcript etc>
>
>Or *is* he registered? Hermione *was* alone in the pet shop for quite a
>while after Ron and Harry fled with Scabbers, she could have been
>filling out the paperwork, yes? Is there any good reason she'd have
>mentioned this? She's not the bragging sort, just to bring it up in
>order to be able to say it. As a Muggle, she might not know all the
>characteristics, so that might explain why she didn't defend
>Crookshanks' actions toward Scabbers on the basis of his Kneazle
>abilities. Whatcha think?

I'm sure Hermione would have registered Crookshanks, had she known he was 
half-Kneazle, but I'm equally sure that, in that case, his behaviour towards 
Scabbers would have made her suspicious, and I can't see her holding back 
this information.  So, I conclude she does *not* know Crookshanks is not an 
ordinary (therefore, of course, extraordinary) cat.
_________________________________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive