Ebony's LOONiness and Welcome Newbie!

[mgrantwich at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 23409

>It makes me feel that we are all getting a bit too nitpicky.  Am I 
>right, or have we overanalysed to the point that it is all we are 
>left with?


Yup.

And to avoid getting thumped by a Moderator, I will add that a lot of 
the analysis focuses on single paragraphs or in some cases even 
single sentences without taking into account the context of the scene 
or chapter.  I don't think JKR ever anticipated the minute analysis 
her books would be subject to on lists like this one and sometimes we 
just have to shrug our shoulders or agree to wait for an explanation 
in a later book.