FAQF Hagrid's Wand
prefectmarcus at yahoo.com
prefectmarcus at yahoo.com
Thu Aug 2 19:07:31 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 23469
I noticed in the wand FAQ several problems concerning Hagrid's wand;
namely (1) How come the umbrellas seems to work but Ron's broken wand
in CoS doesn't, and (2) Why doesn't he buy a new one after CoS.
(1) I have always thought that when they broke his wand, he ended up
with three pieces -- the two wooden halves and the core. The core
would be a lot less brittle than the wood and likely would have
sustained little damaged. What if Hagrid merely put the core inside
the shaft of him umbrella? He now has a functional wand.
Ron, on the other hand, had a broken casing and I believe the core was
damaged as well.
(2) True, it doesn't say he bought a new wand, but it doesn't say he
didn't either. So it really isn't safe to assume he hasn't got a new
wand.
Marcus
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive