Some foreshadowing to Hermione's death??

Sofie Campbell sofie_elisabeth at yahoo.co.uk
Fri Aug 3 12:16:23 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 23523

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Meg Rose" <megrose_13 at y...> wrote:
> Ok, my sincerest apologies if this subject has come up but I was 
> thinking to myself this morning about several instances of possible 
> foreshadowing to Hermione's death:
> 
> The most obvious one is in GoF when Harry rescues her from the lake 
> and she says, (Loose quote here guys, bear with me....) "You did it 
> on your own!  You figured it out!"  I think this is showing how 
Harry 
> is slowly weaning himself off of Hermione's assistance and 
> eventually, when she dies(?) it'll be ok because he is self-
> sufficient??  Ok, that sounded better in my head, but oh well...  
> 
> I believe a similar incident occurs when Hermione is stunned in 
> CoS...  When she gets "unfrozen" doesn't she get excited that he 
> figured it out on his own??  

Ok first I'd like to say, 'NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! She can't kill 
Hermione!' Right now I'm calm. I think you are probably right in the 
respect that Harry is becoming less reliant on Hermione however I 
don't believe that JKR will kill off any of the trio. And if she does 
it is most likely to be Ron. Am I correct in thinking that the 
goddess that is Joanne rowling as said at some point that Ron was a 
planned charcter from the start of the idea and that he has a purpose 
will Hermione is actually a self-insertion of herself. Since Ron 
hasn't actually done much spectaculor yet other than be side-kick to 
Harry I think that he will die to save Harry. If any of those three 
die at all. And, I don't know about the rest of you, but if JKR does 
kill off any of our fab three I will personally be hounding her until 
she re-writes it so they don't die.

Sofie, who will be forced to retreat from all the world if Harry, 
Hermione, Ron, Sirius or Remus dies.(I know I don't ask a lot but i 
will be devastated if any of them do die!)





More information about the HPforGrownups archive