What was the saddest scene for you?

[belinda at sawyertech.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 23898

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., r_e_d_queen at y... wrote:
> How about you guys? Any misty moments while reading the books that 
> you care to admit?
> 

What they said. And . . .

The Patronus lesson. There's Harry, halfway to submitting to the 
boggart/dementor just so he can hear his parent's voices, even as 
they're dying. And Lupin, halfway wishing he could hear them, too. 

I know we're not supposed to talk fanfic here, but Lori captures this 
emotion well toward the end of PoU when she has Sirius tell 
Harry, "You miss having parents, but I miss *James and Lily*." That 
makes sense to me, and it's how I imagine Lupin feels in this scene. 

Belinda