what was the saddest scene?

[jsears at drew.edu]

No: HPFGUIDX 23939

prongs.  when harry sent his patronus across the lake and it came back 
to him in poa, i could not see straight because of the tears.  it was 
the culmination to all the info he had learned about his father that 
night and it sent me over the edge.
also, in poa, any scene that has lupin revealing part of his past 
makes me misty eyed.  that man always gets the short end of the stick, 
it seems to me.
my final poa sad scene is when harry and ron go to hagrid's hut and 
hagrid says his line about valuing friends more than rats and 
broomsticks . . . and they still don't make up with hermione!  i felt 
horrible for her.  her only two friends (as far as we know) are not 
talking to her, she's under stress because of the time-changer ans 
schoolwork, and she's worried about buckbeat and sirius coming to kill 
harry.  what she needs is a hug, not a couple of cold shoulders.  (of 
course, she does get that hug from ron later . . . yeeha!  i guess you 
can tell which ship i'm in favor of!)
--janna