[HPforGrownups] Chapter 8 Summary and Questions

[Bethany]

No: HPFGUIDX 24138

1) Do you think that MWPP have their own drawer in
Filch's office? 
    Also if people have their own drawers like that
why haven't then 
    been expelled? 

I guess it would depend on how long Filch has been
caretaker...I wouldn't be surprised if they had a
couple of drawers. Then again, maybe they just didn't
get cought. They didn't get expelled because Filch
isn't a member of the administration and  can only
hand out detentions. The majority of what he considers
horrible offences are relatively minor; dripping on
the floor,setting off dungbombs, etc. Dumbledore would
have final say on any expulsions and I can't see him
kicking  anyone out  unless they did something really
terrible.

2) Do you think there might be any significance that
Nick died on October 31st, just like Harry's parents?

I hadn't really thought about it before. There could
be. 


3) Do you think all the ghosts at Nick's Deathday
party were witches
    or wizards at one time? When you're a ghost can
you be part of    
    the wizarding world even if you were once a
Muggle?

I think you could be, but ghosts tend to stick around
where they know and most Muggles  don't know the
wizarding world exists.

4) When you read CoS the first time did you wonder why
Filch had a
    KWIKSPELL kit? Did you think he was a Muggle or
just a really badwizard?

I thought he was a really bad wizard and wondered if
that was why he was so cranky.

5) Did you think that Draco had something to with what
happened to Mrs. Norris or at least know who did? 

No, I figured he was to cowardly to be involved
although he would relish the idea of people thinking
him involved.



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Make international calls for as low as $.04/minute with Yahoo! Messenger
http://phonecard.yahoo.com/