DADA teachers
Bente13 at peoplepc.com
Bente13 at peoplepc.com
Tue Aug 14 23:12:55 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 24163
I have a question about something that you guys may have discussed at
length previously, but I'll risk it anyway....
We've heard, in practically every book so far, that Snape seriously
covets the DADA position (although, in all fairness, not from Snape
himself). We have also been told, a couple of times, that it's a hard
position to fill. In CoS, Hagrid says that Gilderoy Lockhart was the
only (on'y) applicant, and in PoA it is likely that Lupin was one of
very few, as Dumbledore probably wouldn't have been allowed to hire
him if there was someone else who could have been hired instead.
(Unless, of course, Dumbledore wanted Lupin there specifically
because of the connection he had with Sirius, but that seems
unlikely, as all the arrangements would have had to have been made in
the short couple of weeks between Sirius' escape and the start of
term.) And of course Moody (the real one) was only supposed to teach
for one year because Dumbledore wanted an Auror at Hogwarts during
the Triwizard Tournament. Anyway, my point is this: if Snape wants it
so badly, and if it's hard to find anyone else who does, do you
suppose there is a reason why Dumbledore doesn't just give it to him
and finds someone else to teach Potions? The DADA position is rumored
to be jinxed, but the Potions one isn't, so presumably it would be
easier to find someone else for that.
Like I said, you may have had long and satisfying discussions about
this already, before my time, but give the newbie a break and let me
know what you think!
Bente
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive