Marauder's Map
lamppost42 at hotmail.com
lamppost42 at hotmail.com
Thu Aug 16 21:08:27 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 24327
> AFAIK, JKR hasn't said anything about her plans for the Map in Book
> Five. My guess is that the Map will be heading back to Filch's drawer
> for good, given its penchant for creating unresolved narrative
> discord - (SNIP!)
I must respectfully disagree, at least with your statement that the map
will return to Filch's drawer. How "Raiders of the Lost Ark"! :) I
suspect the map is headed for a much more glorious future than helping
students sneak out and insulting teachers. Dumbledore seemed geniunely
surprised when Crouch Jr. described Harry's map, suggesting that he was
unaware of its existence (or specific powers). Did Lupin "forget" to
mention it to Dumbledore in PoA? Possibly.
I suspect Filch's predecessor was the one who confiscated the map in
the first place. Filch bears all the earmarks of a Dumbledore hiree
(unfortunate circumstances e.g. being a squib, werewolf, or half-
giant). The "highly dangerous" drawer was probably inherited by Filch
when the Dippet administration came to an end (or maybe they all
snuffed it in the last Voldemort Reign of Terror). I wonder what other
goodies are in that drawer.. not just dating from the Marauders' time,
but maybe even as far back as Tom Riddle's school days...
I'm expecting great things from the Marauders' Map. Perhaps terrible,
but great...
Yours in Wishful Thinking,
Mundungus42
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive