Why didn't Sirius escape? Can Dementors talk?
jessewilliams44 at yahoo.com
jessewilliams44 at yahoo.com
Fri Aug 17 00:31:29 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 24338
Sirius did not escape because the dementors affected him even when he
was in his animargas form. "Harry and Hermione heard a distant
yelping, Sirius is in trouble" The dementors could effect Sirius in
either form, although it was harder when he was in animal form
because his emotions were less complex. Which brings us to my other
questions how do the dementors communicate? In POA early chapters
(sorry do not have book with me, I'm at work) Mr. Weasley tells Mrs.
Weasley that Fudge went to Azkaban, and Black was sane he even asked
Fudge for his newspaper. He also says that the guards told Fudge
that Black had been talking in his sleep always the same words. "He's
at Hogwarts." Do the dementors speak? Or perhaps if they are human
spirits of some sort can they convey their thoughts in writing? Or
could their be other guards that are more humanlike and that still
talk? Maybe even human guards, IMO not likely they would be drained
of all of their happy thoughts.
Jesse
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive