Wands and wandless magic
catherine at cator-manor.demon.co.uk
catherine at cator-manor.demon.co.uk
Thu Aug 23 17:26:35 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 24783
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Jim Ferer" <jferer at y...> wrote:
> Cynthia:"A couple of wand questions:
>
> First, where is Pettigrew's wand? I personally think it got blown
> up or lost) when he blew up the street. That explains why
Pettigrew
> is using Voldemort's wand all the time (except for the time he used
> Lupin's wand to stun Ron and Crookshanks)."
>
> Good question. Your explanation might well be the right one, but it
> could be that Pettrigrew had to hide it when he assumed rat form
and
> has lost it or been unable to return to it in all this time. He
> spent years with the Weasley family, you know.
A couple of questions. Do we know for certain that Pettigrew doesn't
have his wand? In PoA, he dives for Lupin's wand, but that could
just have been because it was easier to get at than his own, which
could have been secreted in a pocket in his robes somewhere.
I haven't the time to trawl through all the references in GoF, but I
am not sure if there is evidence that Pettigrew doesn't have a wand
here, either. I know he uses Voldemort's to kill Cedric, but it is
possible that this was for plot development, seeing as Cedric had to
come out of Voldemort's wand during Priori Incantatem, so he would be
able to ask Harry to take his body back to his parents.
Pettigrew could obviously have had his wand with him throughout the
duration of his life as a rat - he would not have thrown it away, and
would have had it when he transformed and blew up the street during
his confrontation with Sirius. I have always assumed that Animagi do
keep their wands when they transform by putting them in their robes
for safe keeping - afterall, their robes transform as part of
themselves - they don't transform back stark naked, do they?
It also seems unlikely that Pettigrew lost his wand during his
Weasley pet period, because as far as we know, he remained in rat
form the whole time.
I am also wandering how he overpowered Bertha Jorkins - with or
without wand? Did he steal her's and use it against her?
Another explanation is that Voldemort, in order to humiliate
Pettigrew and keep him in line, has confiscated it. This seems quite
probable to me - ensuring that Pettigrew can only do magic in order
to help/serve Voldemort, and not for any other purpose.
Catherine
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive