Wands and Robes for Animagi
pengolodh_sc at yahoo.no
pengolodh_sc at yahoo.no
Mon Aug 27 20:01:35 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 24955
I return briefly from a lengthy period of lurking (in my absence, the
membership of this group seems to have just about doubled itself) for
these questions.
--- In HPforGrownups, Cindy wrote:
[snip]
> I'm still puzzling over this issue of what animagi take with them
> when they transform. It seems they keep their robes. But we learn
> in PoA that when Pettigrew blew up the street, they
> found "bloodstained robes." Yet Pettigrew turns up 12 years later
> wearing robes.
It seems to me that Pettigrew had done some planning in advance on
this bit; the whole charade comes together a bit too well to be
something thought up on the spot when Sirius approached him. My
guess is that the bloodstained robes could have been a spare set
carried with him for the express purpose of being left behind as a
clue. He could also have a spare set stashed away in a convenient
location.
> Also, Black uses Snape's wand in the Shrieking Shack to conjure
> manacles. So when Black transforms into an animagus shortly after,
> why doesn't he keep Snape's wand? I thought that maybe Black did
> keep the wand, and it was confiscated later and returned to Snape,
> but that doesn't make sense, because Snape clearly has the wand as
> soon as he wakes up. Also, if Black had a wand, he could ward off
> the dementors without Harry's help.
I do not have the books handy at the moment (they are due to arrive
by automobile this weekend, along with my TV, 10ft of magazines,
kitchen-utensils, etc. (courtesy of my parents)), and so cannot
verify the following 100% myself, but as I recall, it is not a given
that Snape was using his wand at the moment, just that he was using
*a* wand. Do werewolves keep their clothes with them when they
go "hairy snout"? If not, it could be Professor Lupin's wand. It
could also be Harry's wand, picked up after Harry fainted from the
after-effects of the Dementors, or Ron's or Hermione's wand. Snape
is a quick thinker, I suspect, and would not hesitate to grab the
nearest wand.
Best regards
Christian Stubø
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive