Lily and Snape/Was Re: Cop-out

[opaldragonfly at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 25087

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., Koinonia2 at h... wrote:
> --- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Tabouli" <tabouli at u...> wrote:
> > Diane:
> > >> I still believe the reason that Black and Snape dislike each 
> other 
> > >> has/had to do with a woman.  Whether that is Mrs. Figg 
> (Polyjuice or 
> > >> other potion)I don't know. Surely this woman chose Snape over 
> > >> Black  :-) 
> > > Or maybe she chose neither...what if she was Lily?
> > 
> > Ahaaa!  Yes!  A fellow investor in the Snape/Lily ship building 
> >project that never left Snape's drawing board!  Vampire schmampire,
> 
> I must correct this!  I am the one who said the reason Black and 
> Snape hate each other was/is because of a woman.  I don't believe 
it 
> was Lily.  I absolutely hate the idea of Snape and Lily. I just 
> couldn't have anyone thinking I belonged to that group  ;-)  I have 
> sworn off discussing this subject as I tend to get rather huffy 
when 
> talking about it.  I know I'm in the minority here but that's 
fine.  
> I'm in the minority on the schmampire theory also.  I'm use to it!!!
> 
> Koinonia

Yes--But what if James and Severus were both in love with Lily!?!?  
No there's another reason for Sevvie to resent James and his crew--if 
Lily chiose james!  Opal Dragonfly