Timing of Crouch's escape (was Eagle owls)
Cindy C.
cindysphynx at home.com
Sun Dec 2 15:44:49 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 30568
Amy wrote:
<snip chronology that once again proves Amy's rather impressive
L.O.O.N. credentials>
I'm not following you guys. Why are we sure that the eagle owl is
arriving with a message instead of being sent to deliver a message?
The text is:
"An eagle owl flew through the coil of smoke rising from Hagrid's
chimney; it soared toward the castle, around the Owlery, and out of
sight."
Yes, the owl could have gone into the Owlery or castle after it flew
out of sight. But if it were delivering a message to someone in the
castle, wouldn't it deliver the message right away and go straight
into the castle without the detour around the Owlery? If it were
going to rest in the Owlery first and then deliver the message in the
morning, why doesn't it go straight into the Owlery?
If the owl is in fact being sent from the grounds to deliver a
message, who sent it and what's the message? Hard to say. The
events right before the appearance of the eagle owl are (working
backward):
Conversation with Dobby and Winky in the kitchens
Visit with Sirius in the cave
Karkaroff showing Snape his Dark Mark in Potions class
Harry's performance in the Second Task
Is Karkaroff sending an owl to someone about the appearance of the
dark mark on his arm? Doesn't seem likely. Is Moody sending an owl
to Voldemort informing him that Harry survivied the Second Task?
That makes some sense, although I am unsure how many days pass
between the completion of the Second Task and the eagle owl's
appearance. Can we find a way to implicate Bagman? <vbg>
Cindy (expecting to be shot down by something really obvious that she
missed)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive