Who will Die (Was Re: Harry As Survivor)

[ktchong73 at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 30720

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., idouright2 at a... wrote:
> 
> I have a feeling that Neville mighty die, Ron turn evil over
> jealousy, and Hermione and Harry will live.....like someone said
> earlier history does repeat itself

I also have my own hypothesis about Neville's forgetfulness.  
Neville's grandmother brought him to visit his parents at the mental 
hospital.  Every visit must have been a painful experience for 
Neville, so Neville's grandmother, being overprotecting and wanting 
to relieve her grandson from the pain, cast a memory charm on Neville 
after every hospital visit.  That'd explain why Neville had memory 
problem, why he was so forgetful and dim-witted, and why Neville 
hadn't mentioned his parents to Hermione or any friend (because he 
didn't remember his parents or visiting them.)  We can expect Harry, 
Ron and Hermione to find out about Neville's secret in the future.