Who will Die, Neville

Simonen masi.simonen at kolumbus.fi
Tue Dec 4 22:01:50 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 30770

Someone said "history repeats itself" and people compare the trio and Neville to the Marauders.

So, I´ve always thougt that it´s James - Harry, Sirius - Ron, Remus - Hermione and Peter - Neville. This would mean that Harry would die and Neville would turn evil. Obviously, the similarities and differences between Neville and Peter have been discussed here a lot. I´d sure like to believe that we know enough about Neville to think he´ll not turn like Peter, but I´m a little scared about that...

Also, I think you guys take Ron´s jealousy too seriously. RON IS NOT THE EVIL ONE! He doesn´t talk to Harry for a while, but I can sort of understand him. And I think what Sirius did as a youngster was _much_  worse, when he almost killed Snape. Still he isn´t the DE.

Remember, Ron is Harry´s best friend. When Harry´s alone with Hermione, he certainly misses Ron, but in the Burrow Harry doesn´t seem to miss Hermione very much.

I admit that it hurts to think Harry dying, but nothing denies it either in canon. Of course, this theory is  far-fetched. Especially Neville doesn´t have the same position than Peter. The trio never includes him in anything important. The Marauders were a quartet, HRH is a trio. 

Which leeds me to another subject, is Neville a bit lonely? There´s HRH, then Seamus and Dean and then Lavender and Parvati. Is he left outside? There´s perhaps Ginny, but otherwise...Any thougts?






More information about the HPforGrownups archive