Newbie hi, who will die, James & Lily, Snape & Harry (long)

[kewpiebb99]

No: HPFGUIDX 30945

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Adana Robinson" <adanaleigh at h...> wrote:
> He eventually became a Death Eater for many reasons, but chief 
among them 
> was that he knew Potter never would.  He was still trying to prove 
to 
> himself that he did not _want_ to be good.  It was after James and 
Lily died 
> that he came back to the good side, perhaps because he knew that 
something 
> he did may have contributed to their deaths.  Helping to kill 
someone he 
> refused to admit that he admired may have been too much for him.


no Snape came back to the good side BEFORE the death of James and 
Lily as was indicated in GoF. Dumbledore said Snape turned spy for 
him way before Voldemort disappear.