Snape as Harry's protector (Was: Snape/Harry/Sirius Nov 1, 1981

rosiewolf rosiewolf at hargray.com
Fri Dec 7 03:39:25 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 31024

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "anavenc" <vencloviene at h...> wrote:
> Of course, Harry's mistrust of Snape is the result of Snape's nasty 
> classroom attitude. It was ruthlessly provoked by Snape at their 
very 
> first meeting.  Why, I wonder, Snape chose to alienate Harry ? If he 
> is indeed Harry' guardian, he just brought much trouble on himself.

Perhaps it is more important to the "big picture" that Snape's 
nasty attitude towards Harry get back to the DEs.  They have a very 
effective little spy in that classroom in the person of Draco Malfoy 
who can be trusted to report everything back to Daddy. Both Crabbe and 
Goyle could also be trusted to back up any tales told on Snape.  The 
walls indeed have ears at Hogwarts which could also explain why 
Dumbledore doesn't let Harry in on Snape's role of protector.

Rosiewolf





More information about the HPforGrownups archive