Problem with time travel in PoA

[jenbe_me]

No: HPFGUIDX 31384

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "slurm3001" <r.jeganathan at g...> wrote:
> Hi, I've just read all the messages concerning the time travel in 
> PoA, but I still can't find a logical explanation for the rescue 
from 
> the dementors. 

<snip time travel problems> 

> The problem could have been evaded by Harry managing to do the 
> Patronus the first time, thereby securing his survival to travel 
back 
> in time and rescue Buckbeak.


   "There was only one catch and that was Catch-22..." 

   I think there's quite a few holes in the Time Turner theory, yet 
the best way to deal with them is to have a few drinks, open the 
book, and relax. 

    Either that or get Steven Hawking on the line to explain the 
whole thing.

jenbea