Fame, Glory and Death
pigwidgeon37
pigwidgeon37 at yahoo.it
Thu Dec 13 12:47:41 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 31458
Hi all,
this is something I'd like to discuss with you, as I frankly don't
have any idea what to make of it:
It's about the well-known speech Snape delivers at Harry's first ever
Potions class, "...I can teach you to brew fame, bottle glory and
even how to stopper death" (quoting from memory- I got to buy a set
of books for the office!)
I read and heard it so often now, but today I started to wonder what
exactly it might mean. Only the third part makes sense at first
sight: Surely, there are a lot of deadly potions/poisons. But to what
exactly is Snape alluding when he speaks of fame and glory? They
cannot be the direct result of the potion, as death would be- in the
sense that I can hardly imagine there's a potion you swallow and
suddenly everybody turns round in the street and says: "Look, there's
XY, goodness, how famous he is!"
Neither would I assume that Snape is simply hinting at the
possibility of becoming a famous Potions Master.
Discarding these possibilities, what remains? What makes a person
famous, if it is not the potion in itself? The answer is: Great
Deeds, in whatever sense. And so it would seem that there are potions
which might alter your personality or at least enhance some traits of
your character in order to make you achieve certain goals you would
otherwise be too weak, too cowardly, too obtuse etc.etc. to reach.
Should this be correct, it would open an entirely new perspective on
magic and its limits, for knowing the right potion a wizard would be
able to do nearly everything, good or bad.
That's how far I got with my musings, now please tell me what you
think of it.
Susanna/pigwidgeon37
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive