cedric, killed by voldemort or wormtail
dtklein_2001
flyersfan at swbell.net
Sat Dec 15 05:58:46 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 31627
my first post so hopefully this isnt terribly redundant.
one of the aspects of the graveyard scene that doesnt make sense
to me is whether voldemort or wormtail killed cedric. it appears that
voldemort said "Kill the spare." the voice is described as "high,
cold" and a second voice, described as "schreeched," spoke the Avada
Kedavra curse. it certainly makes no sense that wormtail would order
voldemort to kill cedric.
wormtail is then described as having "lit his wand, and was
dragging Harry toward the marble headstone." later, voldemort is
described as having "slipped one of those unnaturally long-fingered
hands into a deep pocket and drew out a wand."
thus unless wormtail used voldemort's wand to kill cedric there
should not have been the image of cedric discharged from voldemort's
wand after the Priori Incantatem effect. anything i miss that
explains the inconsistency?
Flyersfan
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive