[HPforGrownups] Re: Lupin's Mistake

[mlacats at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 32244

In a message dated 12/16/2001 12:22:24 PM Pacific Standard Time, 
hollydaze at btinternet.com writes:


> 
> The only way that Lupin could have forgotten to take it and for Snape to 
> know, is if Snape never took it to the office, otherwise Snape would have 
> taken it to the office, Lupin would have left it to go chasing after the 
> others and Snape would have never known that Lupin hadn't taken it until he 
> discovers (along with everyone else at the school) that Lupin is running 
> wild in the Forbidden Forrest.
> 

That's it exactly.  Snape had not brought the Wolfbane to Lupin yet....I 
guess Snape has to bring it to him or, at least, on that occasion.  At other 
times, Lupin may have a supply.  I think that Lupin may have just forgot that 
he hadn't taken his potion.  Snape, thinking that there was still time to 
give it to him, was doing just that when he made his discovery.

I'm starting to feel confused.....no more speculating.

Harriet


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]