There's Something Special About Harry...
foxmoth at qnet.com
foxmoth at qnet.com
Fri Feb 2 15:11:02 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 11530
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., cassandraclaire at m... wrote:
> There is a middle ground between "Harry is completely normal and
> possesses no special abilities that everyone else in his year at
> Hogwarts does not possess in equal measure" and "Harry is Batman."
> That's where I stand. (Although he would look lovely in the Batman
> suit.)
>
> Cassie
Odd that you should choose Batman for your analogy, Cassie, since
Batman is the one popular superhero who has absolutely no superhuman
powers. Zip. Nada. He is simply a superbly conditioned and
intelligent human being, not an extraterrestrial like Superman or a
radioactive mutant like Spiderman or a supernatural creature like
Wonder Woman.
As to Super-Harry, I think it does matter whether his extra powers
derive from Voldemort. First, because I think it will create a moral
dilemma about using them, and second because I think such powers are
unlikely to survive Voldie's demise. So adult super Harry, I think,
will remain confined to fan fic, where he can flourish and marry fan
fic Hermione if his heart desires. I don't put much stock in him. All
those delightful fan fics with him tend to concentrate on Hermione,
or Sirius or Draco or somebody. Harry as an adult superhero is
Galahad, the parfait gentle superhuman grail-achieving knight, and he
was a dull character if there ever was one.
Pippin, who wants to borrow Keith's cloning device and make enough
Hermione's to keep everybody happy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive