Angelina/Ages of Hogwarts First Years (was Ron & Quidditch)

[harry_potter00 at yahoo.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 11810

"--Ebony AKA AngieJ (who paradoxically believes that Angelina was a 
sixth year in GoF, but Hermione was 10 when she entered Hogwarts, and 
has absolutely no textual evidence to back it up)"

I agree, but I've never been sure why. In fact I've ALWAYS assumed 
that Angelina was in the same year as the twins. Hermione well I 
think she's younger too. I can't explain it either, I mean she is 
more mature than Harry and Ron after all. Hmmm...perhaps I should 
give some thought to my reasoning.

Scott
(Who thinks that Ron, who's birthday is yet unclaimed, should be 
given May 16th which I realised in the chat on Sunday is shared by 
more than just me!)