I have some Sirius questions here ... seriously :)

find_sam at hotmail.com find_sam at hotmail.com
Thu Feb 15 02:38:29 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 12280

<snip> why 
> would (Sirius) laugh if he were innocent and witnessing Pettigrew 
actually 
> doing the murders?

Maybe Sirius WASN'T laughing at all, but howling with grief at what 
he'd realised just happened: two of his closest friends have been 
killed, and he's just been framed by the traitor. We learn later in 
PoA that laughing and crying can be easily mistook: the trio think 
they've heard Hagrid howling with grief about Buckbeak's death, but 
later learn that he was actually howling with laughter at the 
Hippogriff's rescue.

Sam Brown





More information about the HPforGrownups archive