[HPforGrownups] SW OT

[Stephanie Malfoy]

No: HPFGUIDX 12340

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
If C3PO was created on Tatteroine, then why didn't he recognize it in 4?
If " was created by Anikin (sp?), then why didn't he recognize the
"SKYWALKER" in Luke? Why didn't Obi recognize the two droids?  He ran with 
at least one during Ep 1 (R2D2) Why does Obi tell Yoda about (paraphrased) 
how I was rash when you trained me, when Quo trained him?

Yah, I know.  You guys started this feature in me--critiquing things to
follow in step!

I've got more...just can't recall them at this time!
~~Dee~~
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ahem, just figured I would let my SW know how leak out, if someone else 
answered this, too bad, bc i want to too!  The droids not recognizing 
people/places/things etc ius easily explained...memory wipes.  Obi-Wan 
recognizing the droids is harder to explain.  Many feel he just chose not to 
voice his recognition in fear of scaring Luke.  As to him telling Yoda about 
being rash when Qui Gon Jinn trained him, that is explained that Yoda 
teaches the younger knights, the ones before apprentices, and I am sure as a 
"headmaster" or sorts heis involved in all of the students training.


As to The SW parallels, I look at Yoda as more of a Dumbledore than Obi-Wan. 
  Obi-Wan's character in HP is something more like Sirius to me.  And vader, 
Vader is so not anyone in HP.  He and the Emperor combined make up who 
Voldemort is.  Anyways, May the force be with you...ba ha ha!

Stephanie
Former Star Wars-aholic (just think, it only took me another unhealthy 
obsession, this time with HP, to stop my watching the trilogy 5 times a week 
<vbg>)

_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com