Number of teachers
Jim Ferer
jferer at yahoo.com
Sun Feb 25 16:57:22 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 12975
rhodhry:"Great Britain and Ireland together have 60 million
inhabitants, constituting 1/100 of the world population. With 300
students at Hogwarts, 6000 witches and wizards total (all ages) in
Great Britain and Ireland, you will have (assuming identical
distribution) a world population of 600 000 witches and wizards."
It's worse even than that. My daughters live in a town with 55,000
inhabitants. There are 366 students in six years [not seven] in
there school. I found out there are eleven schools in their town [not
eight or nine like I said in other posts]. IF the number of students
in each school is about equal, then the wizard population of the UK
is closer to 4000 than 6000. Neither way do you have a viable society.
Steve and others have suggested there are alternatives to a Hogwarts
education, and it seems intuitive that would be so, but JKR said once
that a magical quill rights down the name of each magical child born,
that Professor McGonagall checks the book every year, and that she
sends out 'the letter' to those turning eleven.
I believe, like you, that the wizarding population has to be higher
for there to be a viable society. There's no reason to believe that
the wizard birthrate is way different from the muggle population.
I think the real answer is JKR didn't work it all out. It's not as
important as the great stories and characters she's given us, but
there's no 100% way to work out wizard society based on canon and
JKR's statements (excuse me, "revelations."
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive