Is aunt Petunia a witch??

[Maya Crabtree]

No: HPFGUIDX 8281

>Am I the only one thinking aunt Petunia could be a witch? I think she is
but wouldn't admit it. That makes her 'overmuggling' it sometimes. I think
she is the person that knows why Harry has to be with the Dursleys.

you know, that would explain many things. It could mean that in fact, Lily's
parent's could have been wizards, and that we were actually misled about the
muggle-decsent issue (although I am sure that if I reread that bit , I wil
find out that there is no room for error in this matter). nevertheless, I'll
go on with this theory - Assuming this is possible, this means that the
absurd (yet amusing) theory I once had about the "surprising" truly Amercian
style ending of "Voldemort was actually Lily's father / other relative" ,
could actually be possible. I know this is a TERRIBLE idea for an ending, or
a secret hidden behind V's wish to murder harry's father and him, and only
killing Lily because hse defended Harry, but it IS possbile . I wonder if
this list ever discussed such an idea? I presented it to my friend, and she
even went as far as suggesting, that an in the story in the Greek Mythology,
Voldermort might have got a premonition or something of the sort, that his
own grandson (or whatever, they could be related in many different ways) is
going to be the only one who could really bring him down, and decided to
kill him, AND his father in order to prevent it happening. I know this is
hightly unlikely, and I would be very disappointed if JKR decide on
something even similar to it, but I'd just like your thoughts on this, just
the same. :-)

Maya