[HPforGrownups] [Fwd: Re: [Snapefans] LONG--Snape thoughts--let's get rolling...]

[Amanda Lewanski]

No: HPFGUIDX 8636

Amy Z wrote:

> The Snape-Lily-James triangle seems to be considered a fait accompli among
> many fans, but I hope that if we ever do learn why Snape hated James so
> much, it isn't that he was in love with Lily.  That seems predictable in a
> way JKR seldom is.

I agree. I think Snape already hated James, for whatever reasons, which made
Lily's choice all the more unbearable.

--Amanda