Muggle things in Hogwarts
Fefe
fefe at fazekas.hu
Sat Jan 13 02:21:32 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 9104
Hi all !
In GoF, Chapter 28, Hermione explained why Muggle things are useless
in Hogwarts:
"All those substitutes for magic Muggles use - electricity,
computers, and radar, and all those things - they all go haywire
around Hogwarts, there's too much magic in the air. No, Rita's using
magic to eavesdrop, she must be."
Then, i started to think about the Muggle things they used in
Hogwarts and i remembered two things. The first one was the Ford
Anglia, in CoS, and it DID go wrong near Hogwarts... I don't know how
much electronics are in an Anglia, but the ignition system is surely
electric (at least partially) and if it goes wrong, it should be
enough reason for a flying car to fall down :) The other one was
Colin Creevey's camera, also in CoS:
"He was clutching what looked like an ordinary Muggle camera, and the
moment Harry looked at him, he went bright red."
(I think this means that it WAS a Muggle camera.)
Maybe J.K. forgot about this when she wrote GoF, but Colin could have
also used a fully mechanical camera... I think that fully mechanical
Muggle machines doesn't go wrong in Hogwarts, because i can't imagine
any reason for them to do so. When i found this, i was happy because
i just hate those automatic "soap-dish" cameras most people use
nowadays :) I have two cameras, a German (to be correct, Eastern-
German) "Praktica" and a Soviet "Zenit", both of them are quite
professional, fully mechanical, only the light measurement is
electronic. (Zenit is still produced in Russia, and it costs about
$40 :) I'll take one of them with me when i'll visit Hogwarts :)
Btw Harry's watch was surely a magical one, but then, why did it go
wrong underwater ? Oh yes, it could also have been a fully mechanical
Muggle watch, although i can't imagine the Dursleys buying him such
an expensive thing :)
Does anyone remember any other Muggle things that were used in
Hogwarts ?
Bye
Fefe
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive