Self-induced spoilers
Parker Brown Nesbit
pbnesbit at msn.com
Fri Jan 19 15:57:52 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 9721
--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, "Amy " <aiz24 at h...> wrote:
> Cindy's intro post and the various warnings to her reminded me that
I
> actually read the books in the wrong order. I was lent the tapes
by a
> friend who accidentally gave me CS first. Naturally, I had no idea
> what the order was, so I went along, briefly wondering that the
series
> picked up after one year of school, idly wondering at the author's
> decision to hint at me about a recent confrontation with Lord V
> instead of showing it to me, but not tumbling to the fact that I
was
> really, totally out of whack until I was halfway through. I
should've
> stopped much earlier and checked with someone, but I was already
> addicted and I would've had to wait several days before getting a
hold
> of PS/SS.
>
> Fortunately, it really didn't ruin PS/SS for me--all I knew for
sure
> was that Harry wasn't going to die at the end, not a big surprise--
but
> it could have been a bad scene. Gosh, imagine reading GoF before
> PoA--PoA would be ruined by the time you'd gotten to chapter 2.
>
> Anyone else read 'em out of order?
>
> Amy Z
>
> ...who worries deeply about those poor children who actually pay
> attention to the numbers on the spines of the newer Narnia editions
> and read The Magician's Nephew before they read The Lion, the Witch
> and the Wardrobe
>
> ---------------------------------------------
> Crabbe and Goyle chuckled trollishly.
> -HP and the Prisoner of Azkaban
> ---------------------------------------------
Yeah, Amy, I did. The first time. I went to the library (oh
innocent me) to see what "all this *Harry Potter* furor was about &
had to put the books on reserve. CoS came to me first, then SS &
then PoA. It didn't spoil it too much for me. Once I bought the
books, I re-read them in order.
Parker (who's on her 20th(?!) rereading of the series)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive