R/H SW II Theory (was Fanon "ruining" canon (detailed))

Ebony ebonyink at hotmail.com
Sat Jan 20 02:58:01 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 9811

--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, "Tanja Suhinina" <swussian at g...> 
wrote:
> > -George Lucas and JKR's similarities have been noted--what would 
> > Harry, Ron, and Hermione have to say about the Star Wars saga?  
(B. 
> > Bennett, *A Certain Point of View*)
> > 
> Hi! I'm totally new to this egroup. My name is Tanja *feels 
uncomfortable while everyone says "Hi Tanja"*  I saw that George 
Lucas/ JKR thing and remembered that weird essay I wrote a long time 
ago (4 month?:) it's on my site, but since I don't know whether links 
are allowed or not I'll copy-and-paste it into the message. 
> 

Hi, Tanja!  That was a fantastic first post... R/H shippers, did you 
cut and paste that essay?  

I hereby dub this the "R/H Star Wars Parallel Theory".  You've 
definitely written the definitive post for it, Tanja, and B Bennett 
has written the definitive fic.

Once again, I'm impressed.  I was born the year A New Hope was 
released, and Darth Vader was the monster in my childhood 
nightmares.  I loved R2D2 and Yoda the best.  Although I haven't seen 
the original trilogy since I was a little kid, playing Star Wars was 
amongst my fondest memories.

But as I told Flourish over at the Fanfiction list, if Hermione turns 
out to be Harry's sister, and Voldemort is a direct ancestor of Our 
Hero... I quit.

Of course, I've come to expect much more originality than that from 
Jo.  So while the theory is impressive, I'd say the jury is still out.

--Ebony AKA AngieJ
"Still going!  Nothing outlasts those obsessive and "loud" H/Hers!  
They keep going... and going... and going..."





More information about the HPforGrownups archive