Shipper Poll and No-Ship Complaints

ebonyink at hotmail.com ebonyink at hotmail.com
Mon Jan 22 02:33:39 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 10087

I wrote:
> > Thanks!  I didn't even think of them as a real ship.  They're 
> > actually a controlled variable.  Reasoning:  if I had to pair off 
> R/H on the basis of canon, most of the couples in my fic *had* to 
have at least a smidge of evidence from canon.

Amy responded:
> Hmm... I see your reasoning but why look to canon for a 10-years-
hence fanfic at all?  How many people marry someone they liked when 
they were 14?

Up until the last century?   Millions.  :-)  Marvin initiated a very 
interesting conversation about what the wizarding world was like... 
we think that it's both similar and dissimilar to our own.  

If one argues that it is more traditional (i.e. "they're just kids--
they're not late bloomers at all"), then the conclusion can be drawn 
that traditional patterns of mating *could* apply.

As for my fanfic, it's not a fic for fic's sake at all... it's a 
science project.

And every experiment done according to the scientific method has 
controlled variables.

Interesting--we H/Hers get heat from the R/Hers *and* the no-
shippers.  ::::wails::::  No one likes us!

That's probably because we're right.

--Ebony





More information about the HPforGrownups archive