Lupin question

Amanda Lewanski editor at texas.net
Mon Jan 22 03:27:48 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 10100

Susan McGee wrote:

> In the real world, there would definitely be effects of the abuse and
> neglect he suffered. I see some effects in the books, and it's one of
> the reasons that I think it will be long time before Harry enters
> into a serious intimate relationship (someone with a lot of warmth,
> empathy, patience and gayety --- I like Hermione, but I don't think
> she's really the type).

Susan, you're the pro in the field. What do you think of my theory that
Lupin, as the first real close adult contact of Harry's, paved the way for
Moody to be able to get close to him? Dumbledore is an ally, but not a
friend. Lupin was the first adult (that we know of) that Harry got to
spend any time with, got to know, and who was concerned and caring. Sirius
is his godfather, but they've gotten no quality time.

I think if Harry had not developed the friendship that he did with Lupin,
that Moody would have had much more trouble with his machinations.
Thoughts?

--Amanda





More information about the HPforGrownups archive