Star Wars & Ships

[Kimberly]

No: HPFGUIDX 10690

--- In HPforGrownups at egroups.com, Penny & Bryce Linsenmayer 

> I thought of another reason why Harry and Hermione cannot be 
siblings.
> Sirius would *know* this, wouldn't he????!  Besides, lots of people 
(I'm
> not one of them) think that graduation from Hogwarts -- marriage -- 
baby
> Harry happened in very short order.  Hardly time in that scenario to
> have another baby.  And, this theory is especially undercut if 
Hermione
> is in fact 2 months younger than Harry rather than 10 months older.
> Nope ... there's no way they are siblings.
> 


Penny,

I hadn't heard the sibling theory - where did it come from?  Did 
someone find any indication of it, or was it kind of a what if thing?  
Sounds pretty far-fetched to me,  to be honest.  I think I'd feel a 
little cheated if it ended up that way.  JKR could probably make me 
buy it, but I think she can do far better than that.

Oh well, I guess it *would* be neat for Harry to find out he had a 
living relative after all, but not that way...
kimberly