Odp: Odp: [HPforGrownups] Pettigrew vs. Sirius

[Monika Zaboklicka]

No: HPFGUIDX 11201

>Ok, let's be more precise: Acute Stress Disorder, following shock and
>trauma. This would have put him in the state to go after Pettigrew
>and try to kill him because he certainly felt the urge to do exactly
>this (here I totally agree with you), but he was unable to
>concentrate and had no chance against him.

<cut>

Mmmm... I don't have my copy of GoF about me, so just correct me if I'm
wrong, but I think that Hagrid never mentioned that Sirius was in particular
stress when they met at the ruins of Potters' house. I have formed an
impression that this was the reason Hagrid believed that Sirius betrayed
Potters.

And perhaps we'll just agree to disagree? I can *understand* Sirius, but I
don't *like* him, and with Severus it's completely the other way round - I
like the guy even though I don't always understand him. Am I right to say
that your opinions are exactly 180 degrees different?

>Monika
>who still feels the need to defend Sirius...

Monika Z.
(the Snape fan)