MOVIE: Harry's haircolor
Amy Z
aiz24 at hotmail.com
Mon Jul 2 13:38:09 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 21785
Ender asked the reasonable question:
> Where in the books is Harry's hair described as "jet-black" (as
opposed to just "black")?
Oh, wow, a nitpick question that no one has answered yet! My inner
LOON rejoices.
Three of the four first-time-we-see-him descriptions of Harry include
this phrase.
PS/SS 1 (baby Harry described) "Under a tuft of jet-black hair over
his forehead they could see a curiously-shaped cut . . ."
PS/SS 2 (10 y.o. Harry described) just says "black hair."
The description of James in PS/SS 12 just says "black-haired."
CoS 1 says "jet black hair that was always untidy."
PoA 1 says "jet-black hair"
GoF 2 says "untidy black hair."
All of that said, it's true that even "jet-black" Caucasian hair isn't
really as black as jet, viewed up close. I don't know if human hair
comes in true black at all, regardless of race. What I get from JKR's
descriptions is actually in keeping with this fact: namely, Harry's
hair is unusually dark. Then, too, it might be that she is falling
into cliche, that writerly tendency that makes one automatically write
"jet-black" for "black," "white-faced" for "pale," etc.
It is actually all right with me that Daniel Radcliffe's hair isn't
as black as hair can go, partly because the more scenes I see, the
more it looks like what I might at first glance call "black"
(close-ups undermine this view), but also because I am a mature
grownup who does not obsess about the hair color of fictional
children. And because they got his eyes right <g>.
(I don't know if I've ever seen a Caucasion with truly black eyes,
either, but Snape and Hagrid both have them.)
Amy Z
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive