Goblet of Fire

Amy Z aiz24 at hotmail.com
Wed Jul 4 12:12:30 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 21897

Zhi wrote?:
 But from what I understand, when you 
> put 
> > your name into the goblet you also had to put the name of your 
> school 
> > onto the paper, didn't Fred and George do that? And if that's the 
> > case then the paper with Harry's name on it should also have the 
> > school he was representing so it would of been obvious that 
> somebody 
> > was messing with the goblet.
> > 
Catherine wrote:

> I've thought about this too, and often wondered why the name of the 
> school wasn't on the piece of paper.  The only thing I could think 
of 
> was that the name of the school was written in invisible ink, so the 
> Goblet of Fire could recognise it, but that it wasn't visible to 
> human eyes so Dumbledore wouldn't see it.

Maybe only the name of the student comes out on all of them, even 
though they all wrote their school as well.  The parchment comes out 
charred; I get an image of it being purged by the Goblet of everything 
but the glowing name.  Dumbledore would know the school anyway; 
Viktor's name comes out first and he isn't likely to forget which of 
the foreign schools he goes to, and after that it's obvious who goes 
where.

Another possibility is that it =did= say a fourth school and 
Dumbledore just didn't read it out.  Moody/Crouch isn't concerned 
about Dumbledore knowing how it was done (being that he proposes the 
fourth-school theory himself)--so long as he doesn't know who did it 
and doesn't have any way to stop it from going forward.

Amy Z





More information about the HPforGrownups archive