Harry's Victories and the ending...

lilmissiz at aol.com lilmissiz at aol.com
Sun Jul 8 02:01:59 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 22098

"I agree with you here. I think that if Harry doesn't take advanced 
DADA, he's making a HUGE mistake. He needs to get as much learning 
about Defense as he can. He's already proved that he can duel, and is 
lucky. But one day, his luck may run out. Don't hate for saying that. 
It's just...true. Think about it. OK, maybe not in his First and 
Second year, but Fourth Year...that was a little bit of luck for 
their wands to be the same...which we found out in Book One. "
written by: quill_49 at yahoo.com

- i wouldn't call it luck....more like fate....and every time Harry 
defeated Voldemort it was a lucky victory...i mean bk 1 - he didn't 
do   anything...the reason why he survived was only because Voldemort 
couldn't touch himn - otherwise it burned his hand &  also because 
Dumbledore came to save him....in bk 2 harry would have definitely 
died had he not recieved the sword and Fawkes...that was 
chance...then in bk 4 harry would have died for certain if the wands 
weren't brothers - because - although harry is strong - he is not as 
strong as Voldemort....and harry knew nothing of deuling except for 
about 2 or 3 good ones to use...so anyways...harry does need to learn 
- and i think dumbledore should teach him - because harry is going to 
be the first person (other than snape) out of the whole school that 
will be targeted to be killed - so he needs to learn to defend 
himself properly...because the writer is right....his chances will 
run out.. (hopefully in bk 7 and then he can die !!) ...i swear - if 
someone read that sentence without knowing any of my other opinions 
they would just think i hated harry potter...i've decided how i want 
Harry Potter to end......being there are only seven years at Hogwarts 
- i do not believe - or want - Rowling to go any further - it would 
ruin the whole thing......i do believe that she was quite stupid 
about only making 7 years - she should have made 10........so what i 
want to happen is this :
 in book 7 - Voldemort regains the strength and the followers he had 
when he killed the Potters....now he has become stronger than ever - 
and in an effort to prove this - he feels he has to kill Harry ( of 
course )  so somehow Ron and Hermoine both die trying to save Harry's 
life.... Harry then finally kills Voldemort somehow  with the 
knowledge that once Voldmort dies - he must die as well - because 
Voldemort - when he tried to kill Harry - put some of himself in 
harry by means of the scar  - but harry decides he must kill 
Voldemort - otherwise many more innocent people will die instead of 
just one person - so he kills Voldemort....then he suffers sever pain 
for two more days while being visited by many people - we ghet to 
read and experience how he dies as well - then he dies - approx. 2 
days after his final battle despite madame pomfrey's attempts to save 
him.. we then get to see the whole hero ceremony and the school in 
tears - at the deaths of three of the bravest students Hogwarts has 
ever seen ...btw - the last person harry saw on his deathbed - was 
dumbledore - so he felt comfort, serenity, and security   
 ok - thats how i want harry to end - tell me how you want the books 
to end - or if not end - what should come after ????

- Elizabeth






More information about the HPforGrownups archive