Harry's eyes

[Indigo]

No: HPFGUIDX 23112

--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Joel N. Fischoff" <petrukio at e...> wrote:
> On Fri, 27 Jul 2001, Indigo wrote:
> >If Lily was a Seer, she would've known in advance Voldemort was 
> >coming [unless the Death Eaters had some kind of precognition 
jamming 
> >spell] -- and been able to avoid him or get somewhere better 
defended.
> 
> Who is to say that that's not the exact reason for why they cast 
the Fidelus
> Charm?  Just to play devil's advocate.
> 
Except, if Lily was that good a seer, that she knew they'd need 
protective magic as powerful as the Fidelus Charm, she would also 
have known in advance to only trust Sirius as Secret Keeper because 
Petey-boy was working for the big V.  
> 
> >Either way, it would've been less likely to result in Voldemort 
killing
> >both of them and leaving Harry an orphan.
> 
> And who is to say that if they didn't, all three would be dead?
> 
> Joel

Lily as a Seer gives her and James an awful lot of advantage.

If she was as accurate as Trelawney,  one accurate vision out of 
what, every decade?  Then, okay, I guess I'd buy it.

But I still respectfully think that it's not likely.

Indigo