Hermione/Snape/timeturner

Scott insanus_scottus at yahoo.co.uk
Fri Jun 8 04:45:36 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 20410

I've been lurking so to speak for the past few days (off singing the 
songs from Moulin Rouge actually) :-)

The Snape/ vampire theories have been numerous these past few days, 
and are actually having me believing it. There certainly isn't any 
reason not to, afterall we don't know anything about Harry-verse 
vampires.

Long (long, long, long) ago the discussion was going about on 
Hermione's over the top workload in PoA, and I had to comment. 
Someone said the teachers were being insensitive at allowing her to 
get burnt out, but how else would she learn. I know I'd sign up for 
extra classes and a timturner if I had the option. I'd probably end 
up just like Hermione, but I'd much rather find it out than just be 
told 'no'. 

The idea was also raised that the faculty *must* have known about 
Herm's timeturner, especially the one's whose classes she attended at 
the same time. If so then Snape must of known, and Dumbledore's plan 
for allowing Sirius to escape was really dangerous. Not to mention 
that line "Unless you're suggesting they were able to be in two 
places at once..."

Even if Snape didn't know Fudge could have checked ministry records 
(out of curiosity, or am I giving the mand *way* to much credit?) and 
found out that H and H *could* be in two places at once. It wasn't a 
very foolproof plan on reflection, eh?

Scott





More information about the HPforGrownups archive