Blacks in HP (was: Dean again - Bill's living - JKR's activities)
eccleston at clara.co.uk
eccleston at clara.co.uk
Tue Jun 19 22:27:10 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 21183
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Ebony Elizabeth Thomas" <ebonyink at h...>
wrote:
> Haggridd wrote:
>
> >I don't recall any references to Dean's race. The only persons
> >described as black are both friends of the twins: Lee Jordan, and
> >Angelina, who went to the Yule Ball with Gred--or was it Forge? I
> >hope I haven't restated the obvious.
>
>
> Lee's never mentioned as being black... it just states that he has
> dreadlocks. Anyone with a certain type of hair can twist it into
dreads.
> So the probability of him being of another ethnicity is there,
because I
> went to school with a Jewish guy who wore dreads.
>
> Dean's mentioned as black in the American edition of PS (SS 122).
If he's
> not black in the UK, then the obvious conclusion is that Scholastic
did some
> tampering with the MS for profit's sake. A great selling point for
modern
> kidlit is "multiculturalism"--fellow American teachers, how many
> inservices/workshops/conferences have you attended on this theme?
The
> United States has a significantly greater "ethnic" population than
the
> United Kingdom does... bet you anything Scholastic would've put a
Hispanic
> character somewhere in Hogwarts if they could have gotten away with
it. :-D
>
> In a couple of weeks, I'll be in the UK attending summer classes at
Corpus
> Christi. One of my two electives is a comparative US/UK education
course...
> the research paper I plan to do is a comparison/contrast of
literate
> practices between majority/minority children in the schools I'll
survey. I
> wonder if the UK has the same problems educating children who are
not "the
> norm" that our country does.
>
> Of course, we know Hogwarts doesn't have that problem. :-)
>
> --Ebony
I think most people in the UK would assume "dreadlocks = black".
White people with dreadlocks really is quite unusual here
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive