[HPforGrownups] Jumbled thoughts on how Harry could have killed Sirius

Sylph ~*~ kabuki_darling at hotmail.com
Wed Jun 27 03:37:25 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 21508

Catherine wrote:
I have often wondered how Harry was going to kill Sirius.  The
>conclusion I came to, was that Harry has on occassions, let his
>emotions get the better of him and performed uncontrolled magic - the
>blowing up of Marge is an excellent example of this.  Would it
>therefore be a natural progression to assume that Harry's anger over
>Sirius' alleged betrayal of his parents is an anger which is a huge
>magnification of his anger at Aunt Marge?  If he can blow up his aunt
>as a result of his anger, is it possible that his anger during this
>scene, which must be much stronger, could allow him to kill someone,
>without knowing exactly how to do so?  The fact that he is holding
>his wand could serve him to channel his anger, thereby making his
>actions more effective.

Me: Wow-that's a very good idea, and it made me think of another 
possibility. Several of the more advanced wizards/witches are seemingly able 
to perform magic without muttering an incantation. For example. Molly 
Weasley skinned potatoes and made a dustpan pick them up with a point of the 
wand. Bill and Charlie battled tables, repaired a table leg, and conjured 
tablecloths with a flick of the wand. Dumbledore delivered hundreds of 
sleeping bags with one point. Perhaps all these people had to do was imagine 
what they wanted, and channel it to the wand. Perhaps all Harry needed to do 
was imagine Sirius dying, and channel it through his wand!

Sylph
_________________________________________________________________
Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com





More information about the HPforGrownups archive