musings about things, mostly PoA Chapter 17

James Handley jwh at comp.leeds.ac.uk
Thu Jun 28 09:28:58 UTC 2001


No: HPFGUIDX 21569

Zarleycat at aol.com wrote:
> 
> Harry goes through an internal dialog about killing Crookshanks, 
> too.  He tries to convince himself that Sirius deserves to die and 
> hears the voice in his head say, "Do it now"  but doesn't act on that 
> command. Plus, Sirius tells him he doesn't know the whole story about 
> his parents' deaths.  That pushes a button with Harry.  

Reading this made me think about the imperio curse.. perhaps scabbers
could muster up enough magic to do half an imperio (because if Harry had
killed Sirius, that could only be beneficial for scabbers and V.)

I don't /really/ think that, but it's the thought that came to mind! :)
 

J,





More information about the HPforGrownups archive