SHIP--Ron and the Yule Brawl (yawn)
Ebony AKA AngieJ
ebonyink at hotmail.com
Mon Mar 5 22:45:51 UTC 2001
No: HPFGUIDX 13663
The real SS H/H (clarification: the one on which Hedwig is just
Harry's courier pet and *nothing more*) appears in the distance.
It is being trailed by the Good Ship R/H... a self-destructing VIP
message has fallen into the hands of a certain vacationing Special
Agent... all other ranking H/H officers are otherwise occupied around
the HP Fan World, as active H/Hers tend to be busy types.
On a nearby tropical island, Agent Ebony waves off the handsome
Jamaican wizard-masseuse and sets her margarita on the beach blanket
with a sigh. "Call that a holiday? I thought they were *done* with
main-list shipping until the schoolbooks come out!" Sighing, she
tosses aside the message before it explodes, zips up her wetsuit, and
dives back into the choppy waters of the Shipping Seas.
--- In HPforGrownups at y..., "Kimberly" <moongirlk at y...> wrote:
"While I agree with Simon that it wouldn't have made much sense in
the context for Hermione to include Harry in that statement, I
respectfully submit that that does not explain why she would not have
chosen, as Mo says, to use a different retort alltogether. Why, if
Hermione would prefer *not* to date Ron, would she not only suggest
that he ask her out in the future, but also suggest that she would
go - by implying that had he asked her to the ball first, it would
have "solved" the problem. "Well if you don't like it, you know what
the solution is, don't you? Next time there's a ball, ask me before
someone else does, and not as a last resort!"
"She could easily, as Mo said, have told him to go soak his head, or
to stay out of her personal business, or that she didn't need him to
tell her who to date, but instead she said that to solve his problem,
he should ask her out. Is she being cruel, setting him up to fail?
Doesn't seem like her."
--------------------
Penny's going to kill me, and so will the rest of my shipmates. But
I'll begin my approach to the Yule Brawl with this: I grudgingly
agree with most of the R/H platform. It was after reading the Yule
Ball scene on July 8 that I mentally picked up an R/H pennant, glared
at it, and waved it with a halfhearted "Whoop-dee-doo." ;-)
Having conceded that, a whole realm of possibilities are opened up.
There's another, deeper level of reasoning that could be at work on
Hermione's part.
Taking for granted FITD (new members, check the archives--no time to
explain it), IF Hermione's remarks were intended as encouragement to
Ron, they may have been prompted by several other factors, none of
which necessarily include "wow, I'm really starting to see Ron in a
different light!"
I'd elaborate at length, but this list is still on webview, and I'm
on vacation. :::Applause from the veterans!::: Shipmates, just send
me another message off list if the gloating continues... I just
finished re-reading GoF, and I'd dearly love to use the R/H reading
of the Yule Brawl to illustrate some of our points. Besides, that
masseuse of mine isn't going anywhere. :)
I leave you with this cheesy paraphrase from the movie Titanic: "A
woman's heart is a deep ocean of secrets." Cliche? Yes. But aren't
cliches just truths in proverbial form?
Who knows what going on with Hermione's? We certainly don't... and
that's because Hermione's thoughts and feelings are not something
Harry's really interested in at this juncture. (Waves at Jim Ferer--
I owe you an e-mail.)
There is a silver lining in canonical R/H IMO... since the books are
told from Harry's point of view, we won't be subjected to it very
much. I can't imagine he'll be terribly interested in giving us a
blow-by-blow of R/H, either.
Let us hope that if JKR is really the captain of the OBHWF Cruise
Lines *in absentia*, Harry in the remaining books will be too busy
fighting Voldemort/learning more about his parents and the
past/trying to stay alive to moon over Ginny too much. :-)
Swimming away...
--Ebony AKA AngieJ
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive