Snape as Death Eater

[Tina Smart]

No: HPFGUIDX 14233

Snape seems to be everyone's favourite topic at the moment, and I just had a 
thought.

Was Snape already a spy (Dumbledore's spy)? Was he working for Dumbledore 
all the time? No one has questioned his loyalty to Dumbledore, and maybe it 
extends further than the last 14 years.
We have all thought that maybe he would go back to the death eaters as a 
spy, but maybe he was that from the very beginning. He is nasty on the 
surface, but how many times has he helped harry? Under all that surface 
nastiness he has shown himself as a caring and loyal person. He would still 
need to appear mean to be believed by the death eaters that he has come 
back.
I think that obviously that will be addressed in one of the future books, 
but I see this as just as much a possibility as him truly having been a 
committed death eater.

Any thoughts?

Tina.
_________________________________________________________________________
Get Your Private, Free E-mail from MSN Hotmail at http://www.hotmail.com.